Nora Dunn
Clay Jarvis
Beth Buczynski
Because Sharia law prohibits riba, or loans that charge interest, conventional mortgages are forbidden for practicing Muslims. To meet the spiritual and financial needs of Muslim homebuyers, a number of Canadian lenders are now offering halal mortgages.
Many Canadians might associate “halal” with food, but the term actually applies to Muslim society in general, and describes behaviours and activities — including lending — that Islam deems permissible.
Halal mortgages eliminate the payment of interest by using different legal and payment structures. Let’s find out how they work and where they’re available in Canada.
What ‘halal’ means for a mortgage
According to Sharia law, riba is seen as exploitative: borrowers are forced into a never ending cycle of debt at the expense of lenders, who reap continual profits.
That doesn’t mean halal mortgages remove profits from the equation. Instead of interest rates, a halal lender might charge a “profit rate”. Even though these profit rates can be based on the Bank of Canada overnight interest rate, they tend to be higher than the rates attached to conventional, non-halal mortgages.
The increased cost is due to a variety of factors, including a general scarcity of available capital to lend out, as well as increased financial risk to the lenders since Islam also restricts mortgage foreclosures.
Consumers can generally expect to pay up to an additional 4% for a halal mortgage compared to a regular mortgage from one of the major banks.
Types of halal mortgages
The three shariah-compliant mortgages are Murabaha, Ijara, and Musharaka. Each has a different structure and method for transfer of ownership.
Murabaha
Under a typical Murabaha agreement, the financier buys the property and immediately sells it to you (the customer) at a higher price that includes a profit. The amount of profit is based on a number of factors including your risk profile, credit history, deposit amount, the property value, and repayment term.
Instead of owning the property as an individual, you hold the property title within a corporation that you set up for this purpose. Unfortunately this makes you ineligible for the land transfer tax rebate available to first-time home buyers in some provinces.
There are, however, variations of Murabaha available in Canada where the borrower assumes ownership of the property directly without having to take the step of purchasing it through their lender.
Ijara
An Ijara mortgage is similar to a rent-to-own scheme. The financier buys the property outright and rents it to you for a fixed term. Over this term you make regular steady payments, which are a combination of rent, repayment of capital, and profit for the financier. At the end of the agreement, ownership is transferred to you.
Musharaka
With a Musharaka mortgage agreement, both you and the financier own the property jointly. Your payments are a combination of rent for the portion of the property owned by the financier, and property purchase payment to buy a little bit of financier’s share until eventually, at the end of the term, you own the whole property.
Like typical Western mortgages, halal mortgages offer a variety of terms, conditions and fees. Some Murabaha agreements, for example, do not allow for additional payments, while some Musharaka mortgage customers can pay up to 20% extra per year without penalty.
It’s very important to understand the details of any halal mortgage product and evaluate your options based on your needs and financial situation.
Where to find a halal mortgage in Canada
An Islamic mortgage in Canada can currently be obtained through the following lenders:
Eqraz and Manzil are both members of the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions. The AAOIFI is an international not-for-profit organization located in Bahrain that regulates Islamic finance organizations and offerings to be Shariah-compliant.
The Canadian Halal Financial Corporation is not a member of the AAOIFI, but it does adhere to the organization’s standards and has had its products deemed halal by experts in Sharia law.
In addition to the three Canadian halal mortgage providers, there is also a US-based company called IjaraCDC that offers halal mortgages to Canadians.
Qualification requirements for a halal mortgage in Canada
The qualification requirements for halal mortgages in Canada will depend on the provider. They will likely review your income, credit history, and may require a down payment of at least 20%. Halal Financial Corporation, however, requires a minimum down payment of 25%.
Halal mortgage challenges in Canada
With halal mortgages being an emerging product in Canada, and Canada’s tax law posing some unique challenges to Islamic mortgages, it’s confusing to know which mortgages are truly compliant with both Sharia and Canadian laws.
According to the Eqraz website, Musharaka mortgages may be non-Shariah-compliant with the use of interest-bearing secondary contracts.
Eqraz also suggests that both Musharaka and Ijara mortgages are incompatible in Canada for a variety of reasons, including double capital gains and land-transfer taxation, GST/HST-taxable maintenance responsibilities, and, in the case of diminishing Musharaka mortgages, complications regarding who takes on the downside risk despite co-ownership of the property.
Frequently asked questions about halal mortgages
While buying a house with a conventional interest-bearing mortgage is not halal, there are specialized financial services available from Shariah-compliant financial providers that provide halal mortgages.
At this time, RBC does not offer a halal mortgage, nor do any of the Big 6 banks. If a bank offers mortgages that charge interest, which all Canadian banks do, those loans are not halal.
About the Author
About the Author
DIVE EVEN DEEPER
Types of Mortgages in Canada: Which Is Right for You?
There are many types of mortgages in Canada. Common home loan options, like, closed and conventional are just the beginning.
How The Tax-Free First Home Savings Account Can Help You Buy A House
The First Home Savings Account combines beneficial aspects of an RRSP with those of a TFSA to help Canadians save for a home purchase.
Kurt Woock
FHSA, TFSA or HBP: Which Is Best for Hopeful Homeowners?
Here’s how to choose between or even combine the FHSA, HBP and a TFSA as part of your down payment savings strategy.
How to Build Credit as a Newcomer to Canada
Building credit is an important part of starting your new life in Canada. It requires applying for the right credit products, using them responsibly and paying all of your bills on time.